Most apparel returns in the US are decided by three things, in this order: the clock (a window measured from purchase or from delivery, depending on the retailer), the proof (a receipt or order record that determines whether you get money back or credit), and the condition (tags on, unworn, original packaging). Get any one of them wrong and the item comes back to you. The windows themselves vary enormously — Walmart's standard policy allows 90 days for most items, IKEA US gives 365 days on new and unopened goods but 180 on opened ones, and SHEIN USA runs 30 days from the delivery date rather than the order date. Knowing which clock your retailer uses, and what it demands at the counter, is most of the work.
Which date starts the clock: purchase date or delivery date
The clock starts on the purchase date at most brick-and-mortar retailers and on the delivery date at most online ones, and the gap between those two dates is dead time you can't recover. SHEIN USA is explicit about this: its US policy specifies that most items may be returned within 30 days from the delivery date, subject to listed return requirements and non-returnable item exceptions. Order on a slow shipping tier and the month you thought you had is closer to three weeks.
The practical consequence is that you should not treat "30 days" as a single concept. A 30-day window from purchase at a store means 30 days from the moment the card is charged. A 30-day window from delivery means 30 days from the day the parcel lands — which is why the delivery confirmation email, not the order confirmation, is the document worth keeping. If a package sits in a lobby for four days because nobody was home, that's four days off the end.
Longer windows invert the problem. IKEA US allows returns of new and unopened products within 365 days of purchase and opened products within 180 days, and Walmart's standard policy gives 90 days after purchase or receipt for most items unless exceptions apply. With windows that long, the risk isn't running out of time — it's losing the receipt and the manufacturer packaging over the course of a year. Walmart specifically recommends keeping manufacturer packaging and the receipt for at least 90 days after purchase, which tells you what the counter will ask for.
The limit: exceptions override the headline number at every one of these retailers, and the exception list is longer for apparel than for almost any other category. Worn garments, altered hems, washed items and anything missing its tags routinely fall outside the standard policy even when the calendar still has days on it.
Receipt or no receipt: what proof of purchase actually buys you
A receipt is what converts a return into a refund to your original form of payment. Without one, you are usually negotiating for store credit, a lower refund based on the current selling price, or nothing at all. Menards is the bluntest example: its Returns & Exchanges page states that TD products may be returned or exchanged within 30 days of purchase with a receipt and ND products within 90 days of purchase with a receipt, and that no returns, refunds, exchanges, or credits will be issued without a receipt. No receipt, no transaction — not a worse transaction.
IKEA US sits in a similar place. It offers a long return period — 365 days for new and unopened products, 180 days for opened ones — but proof of purchase is required for a full refund to the original payment method or a refund card. The window is generous; the documentation requirement is not negotiable.
The definition of proof of purchase is broader than a paper slip. A receipt, an order confirmation or a transaction record all count at most retailers, and a loyalty account or a card statement showing the charge often works where paper has vanished. What does not work is a photograph of the item, a friend's confirmation email, or a gift receipt presented as if it were a full one — a gift receipt typically unlocks credit, not cash, because it doesn't tie the purchase to a payment method.
This is where the cost shows up. Keeping receipts for apparel means keeping them for the length of the longest applicable window — which, at a retailer with a 365-day policy, is a year of filing. The alternative is accepting store credit as the default outcome and treating the refund as the bonus. That's a defensible trade if you shop at the same place repeatedly; it's a bad one if you don't.
Refund, merchandise credit, or exchange: three different outcomes
Retailers separate these deliberately, and the split is often a matter of days rather than eligibility. Ulta Beauty states that most new or gently used products returned within 30 days of the original purchase date are eligible for a refund to the original form of payment, while returns made from 31–60 days of the original purchase date are eligible only for merchandise credit. The item is still returnable at day 45. The money just isn't coming back to your card.
That structure is worth understanding because it's increasingly common: a first window for cash, a second window for credit. It changes the arithmetic of a late return. If you paid with a card and the refund would have gone back to that card, merchandise credit is a worse outcome by exactly the amount you'd rather have in cash — but it's still better than a rejected return, provided you will actually spend it at that retailer. Credit that expires unused is worth nothing.
Exchanges are a third path and often the cheapest for the retailer to grant, which is why they sometimes survive when a refund wouldn't. A size swap on an unworn garment with tags is usually the easiest transaction in the store. The complication is stock: if the size you need is gone, the exchange becomes a refund or credit, and you're back to the window rules.
Original form of payment matters more than people expect. Refunds are typically issued back to the specific card, debit account, gift card or digital wallet used in the initial transaction. If that card has since been cancelled, replaced or closed, the refund can fail or be reissued as credit — a sequence that adds days and usually requires a phone call rather than a counter visit.
Apparel-specific condition rules: tags, wear, and wash
Apparel is judged on condition more strictly than almost any other return category, and the judgment happens in front of you at the counter. The baseline is unworn, unwashed, with tags attached and original packaging where there was any. A garment that has been through a washer loses the return even if the calendar is wide open — the retailer can no longer resell it, and the policy language about "new or gently used" is doing real work there.
The failure modes are consistent and boring. Tags removed before you decided to keep the item. Deodorant or perfume transfer on a neckline. A hem that was taken up. Shoes worn outdoors, where the soles tell the story instantly. Missing belts, detachable straps and fabric swatches that came in the bag. None of these are policy disputes; they're condition disputes, and condition disputes are decided by the person holding the garment.
The trade-off is real: to preserve returnability you have to delay wearing and washing, which means buying early and deciding late, or accepting that a garment you've worn is yours. Trying something on over existing clothing, keeping tags on until the first proper wear, and holding the original bag and packaging until you're sure are cheap habits that preserve the option. They cost you a corner of a drawer for a few weeks.
Where the rules bite hardest is in the second window — the credit window. Retailers are often more willing to accept a slightly handled item when the outcome is store credit rather than cash, because the money stays with them. That's not a written rule anywhere, but it's the pattern the refund/credit split produces.
Retailer-by-retailer: how the windows actually compare
The headline numbers differ by an order of magnitude, and the differences track the category rather than any principle. A cosmetics retailer runs a tight window because the product is consumable and hygiene-sensitive; a furniture retailer runs a long one because the decision is expensive and slow. Apparel sits between those poles depending on where you bought it.
| Retailer | Window | Measured from | Key condition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Walmart (standard policy, most items) | 90 days | Purchase or receipt | Receipt recommended; keep manufacturer packaging at least 90 days |
| SHEIN USA (most items) | 30 days | Delivery date | Subject to listed return requirements and non-returnable item exceptions |
| IKEA US — new and unopened | 365 days | Purchase | Proof of purchase required for full refund |
| IKEA US — opened | 180 days | Purchase | Proof of purchase required for full refund |
| Menards — TD products | 30 days | Purchase | Receipt required; no returns without one |
| Menards — ND products | 90 days | Purchase | Receipt required; no returns without one |
| Ulta Beauty — refund to original payment | 30 days | Original purchase date | Most new or gently used products |
| Ulta Beauty — merchandise credit | 31–60 days | Original purchase date | Credit only, not a refund |
| Ulta Beauty salon services | 7 days | Service date | Service satisfaction window |
Two things jump out of that table for anyone buying clothes. First, the retailers with the longest windows are the ones that demand proof of purchase most firmly — length and documentation trade against each other. Second, the shortest window in the set belongs to SHEIN USA at 30 days, and it runs from delivery, which makes it shorter in practice than the number suggests.
The limit of any comparison table is that exceptions are where returns actually get decided. "Most items" is doing heavy lifting in Walmart's and SHEIN's policies alike, and the non-returnable list is where the answer to your specific question lives.
Common misreadings that cost people money
Several widespread beliefs about return windows are simply wrong, and each one causes people to give up on a return they were entitled to make. The most expensive is the idea that Ulta only accepts returns within 30 days and will not take products back after that. Ulta's official guest services page explains that returns made from 31–60 days of the original purchase date are still accepted, but are eligible for merchandise credit rather than a refund to the original form of payment. People who believe the 30-day version throw away a return they could still make.
The second is that IKEA US will not accept returns of opened products. IKEA's US return policy explicitly states that opened products may be returned within 180 days of purchase with proof of purchase for a full refund, in addition to the 365-day window for new and unopened products. Assembled furniture and opened packaging are not automatic disqualifiers there — the receipt is the thing that matters.
The third is that Menards offers the same return window for all products. Menards distinguishes between TD products, which have a 30-day return or exchange window with a receipt, and ND products, which have a 90-day window with a receipt, and notes that no returns are processed without a receipt. If you assume the shorter window applies to everything, you'll miss the longer one on the items that carry it.
There's a fourth pattern that isn't a myth so much as a habit: treating the order date as the start of the clock at online retailers. SHEIN's policy is the clean counterexample — 30 days from the delivery date, not the order date — and the same structure appears across e-commerce generally. The date on your confirmation email is the wrong date to count from.
The cost of all four misreadings is the same: an eligible return that never gets made. The fix is unglamorous — check the specific retailer's policy page for the specific item, note which date the window runs from, and keep the receipt until the window closes rather than until the item is worn once.










